So here we are, summer of 2007 and I'm waiting for the classic hits to take their place in the pantheon of pop. Several months ago I wrote about the magic that seems to have taken place in years ending in sevens, though I admitted that this trend has been in decline since the peak year of 1967. Here are comparative lists of the big hits from the first halves of the 7th years of the past several decades:
1967
I'm A Believer - The Monkees
Ruby Tuesday - The Rolling Stones
Penny Lane - The Beatles
Happy Together - The Turtles
Something Stupid - Frank and Nancy Sinatra
Groovin' - The Young Rascals
Respect - Aretha Franklin
Not to mention a few "minor" hits from the Supremes ("Love is Here and Now Your Gone" and "The Happening.") Beatles, Stones, Sinatra, Aretha and Diana, all atop the charts between January and June 1967. 'Nuff said!
1977
Tonight's the Night - Rod Stewart
I Wish - Stevie Wonder
Blinded By the Light - Manfred Mann (but written by Bruce Springsteen)
Evergreen - Barbra Streisand
Dancing Queen - Abba
Hotel California - The Eagles
Sir Duke - Stevie Wonder
Dreams - Fleetwood Mac
Got to Give It Up - Marvin Gaye
I admit, this list steers dangerously close to MOR but even if it's not the most rockin' set of tunes you ever heard, there's no doubting the heft,significance and sheer talent of the performers listed above. And seething underneath it all was punk rock and Eurodisco innovators like Kraftwerk who were laying the foundations for musical breakthroughs that would sustain us culturally for the next couple of decades at least.
1987
OK I admit, my argument is beginning to get strained here but let's see what I can do to salvage my case...
Walk Like an Egyptian - The Bangles
Jacob's Ladder - Huey Lewis and the News
I Knew You Were Waiting For Me - Aretha Franklin and George Michael
Open Your Heart - Madonna
With or Without You - U2
Well, that's about all I can put forth as far as "lasting talent" is concerned. There was some truly cheesy music put out that spring (Livin' on a Prayer by Bon Jovi, Lean on Me by Club Nouveau, Nothing's Gonna Stop Us Now by Starship) and then there were a few good songs released by ephemeral performers (Shake You Down by Gregory Abbott, Died In Your Arms by Cutting Crew, Always by Atlantic Starr.) Let me just remind you that U2 was in their prime (one of their primes, I'll even say) and Whitney Houston was several years away from disgracing herself. Then again, we have to take Lisa Lisa and Cult Jam into account... I'll just leave it at that and move on to 1997.
1997
Un-break My Heart - Toni Braxton
Wannabe - Spice Girls
Can't Nobody Hold Me Down - Puff Daddy feat. Ma$e
Hypnotize - Notorious B.I.G. (peaked just after Biggie was shot to death)
MMMBop - Hanson
I'll Be Missing You - Puff Daddy, Faith Evans, 112
OK, I'm under some stress here. That's the complete list of #1 hits from '97 through the end of June. I now discern that the slide has been gathering momentum for a couple of decades now. I suppose that Puff Daddy a.k.a. Puffy a.k.a. P Diddy a.k.a. Diddy (now) or Sean Combs as I generally think of him (when I do) may rank as a figure of lasting importance but it will never be about the music. The other names on this list are either non-entities or novelty acts (though I will say I like Toni Braxton's voice, I just wish she hadn't gotten so desperately sleazy as her career progressed - she had the makings of a great, classy torch singer but the industry doesn't sufficiently reward that style anymore I guess.)
Though there was some good music released that year, it didn't make it to the pop charts, I'm sad to admit.
2007
Here's where we are at now, folks. Tell me if you think any of these performers will have comparable staying power to the Hall of Famers we heard from in 1967 or even '77:
Irreplaceable - Beyonce (maybe?)
Say It Right - Nelly Furtado
What Goes Around Comes Around - Justin Timberlake
This is Why I'm Hot - MIMS
Glamorous - Fergie feat. Ludacris
Don't Matter - Akon
Give It to Me - Nelly Furtado feat. Justin Timberlake
Girlfriend - Avril Lavigne
Makes Me Wonder - Maroon 5
Buy U a Drank (Shawty Snappin') - T-Pain feat. Yung Joc
Umbrella - Rihanna feat. Jay-Z (I actually like this song, once Jay-Z shuts up, the best of all others that have topped the charts this year.)
I will say one thing in favor of this list though, that no song sits on top for too long the way that, say, Mariah Carey and Boyz II Men did back in the 90's (way out of proportion to both their talent and the worthiness of their songs.)
OK, that's what I have to say, you can comment on this if you think you got something to say to me about it.